Western Prince WilliamNIMBY SOCIETY
A red-roofed home overlooks two rows of houses on the hillside. Two yard signs read “Save our rural character*” with “*as viewed from our deck” and “No new houses” with “after mine.”

Stop the development of Western Prince William.

We moved here for the quality of life. Imagine our surprise when the next family wanted to do the same.

The aerial archive

Before the backyards.

Choose a neighborhood to read its exhibit. Slide across the county’s aerials to compare the same ground in 1995 and 2025, or look further back to 1937.

Exhibit A

Heritage Hunt

Before:
Heritage Hunt in 2025, with fairways and rows of houses on curving streets. Heritage Hunt in 1995. An oval horse track near the top of the frame, with fields and woods to the south. 1995 · Before2025 · After
Drag the divider to compare.Prince William County GIS aerials
Location
Gainesville, north of Route 29
Zoning
PMR
Homes
1,863
Built
1998 to 2009

This was a horse farm. The oval track is still visible near the top of the 1995 photograph. Today the horses are remembered on the street signs at Breeders Cup Drive, Paddock Court and Saddle Run Way. The horse pasture is an 18-hole Arthur Hills golf course, which we continue to describe as open space.

Image sources & full-size aerials

Each pair covers the same portion of its neighborhood at the same scale. The 1937, 1995 and 2025 photographs come from Prince William County GIS. Older photographs may show small alignment differences.

What our neighborhoods did to the look of the county

We take no pleasure in saying this about our own homes. The photographs leave us no choice.

  1. The view

    West of Route 15, open fields once ran toward the Bull Run Mountains. Our rooflines now occupy the foreground. We chose the shingle colors ourselves, from an approved list of three.

  2. The farmland

    About 3,350 acres of working land went under our streets, lawns and fairways. Every acre lost is a tragedy. We can say so with authority, because we are standing on them.

  3. The traffic

    Some 5,400 households now pull out of these three neighborhoods onto Route 15, Route 29 and Catharpin Road. We are firmly against the traffic. We would also like it noted that we are the traffic.

  4. The rural character

    We moved here for the rural character. Our moving here ended it. We have not forgiven the people who arrived after us.

  5. The open space

    Our golf courses are green, quiet and unbuilt. They qualify as open space in every respect except being open.

  6. The precedent

    Each of our neighborhoods exists because the county approved a rezoning. We now attend hearings to warn the county against approving rezonings. We speak from experience.

Our position

The restoration
resolution.

Western Prince William lost something when a view across several fields became a view across six garage doors. We believe those fields were worth keeping. This creates a small problem for those of us who own the garage doors.

In the interest of consistency, the Society proposes that the homes in Dominion Valley, Oak Valley and Heritage Hunt be voluntarily vacated, the pavement lifted, and the land returned to the fields and woodland visible in 1995.

Supervisor Stewart might endorse this program right up to the moment he learns it includes his house.

The Only Solution

Notice of proposed
rezoning

Case
REZ-NEVER-0001
Applicant
Western Prince William NIMBY
Request
Rezone about 3,350 acres from RPC, PMR and SR-1C to A-1, Agricultural
Subject property
Our houses
Hearing date
Deferred until we agree on a year
  1. Vacate

    All 5,400 households move out. We will go first, as soon as we find comparable homes with rural views and a guarantee that nothing will be built nearby.

  2. Remove

    Houses, clubhouses, cul-de-sacs, cart paths and entrance fountains are taken out. The gatehouses come down last, so the work can proceed in privacy.

  3. Restore

    The land is regraded and reseeded in pasture grass. Fence lines go back where the 1995 photographs show them. Horses return to Heritage Hunt.

  4. Protect

    The restored fields are placed under permanent protection, so that no one can ever again do to them what we did.

The founders’ invitation

Conservation begins at home.

We invite the founders of Audacious NIMBY and the Coalition to Protect Prince William County to lead the way. By placing their own home properties under conservation easements, they could preserve the land for future generations. This includes removing their accessory buildings and manmade ponds and restoring all the trees that were cut down. At the next meeting, when somebody asks which land to protect first, they could stand up and say, “Ours.”

Waiting for the conservation easement paperwork

1,374 days and counting

The Society’s eastern proposal

Send it all east.

All new development should go to eastern Prince William County. Every house. Every warehouse. Even the coffee shop, provided it still delivers to Haymarket.

In Gainesville, a new subdivision would spoil the view. In Woodbridge, the very same subdivision would be what our committee calls “a welcome investment.”

We invite our neighbors in Eastern Prince William to answer the question of where new development should go. We’ve narrowed it down to your side of the county. We’d be delighted if Eastern Prince William could find room for all 56,000 homes. We checked out here, and every available field is part of someone’s view.

Suggest an Eastern Prince William site
Belmont Bay’s waterfront, marina, curving residential streets and wooded areas in eastern Prince William County.
Belmont Bay, Woodbridge2025 aerial · County GIS

Housing Shortage is only a problem for people without a house

56,000 homes.

Needed for Prince William residents.
With a Stafford or Fauquier home address.

The gap between the 2020 housing supply and projected 2040 demand is 56,240 homes. That includes the shortfall already present in 2020. Read Table 5-2 in the county study.

Dear Stafford and Fauquier,

Would you open your doors and start building homes for Prince William residents? Our children are looking for their first places. Our teachers would like to live close to school. The Western Prince William NIMBY Society would be delighted if you could find room for the 56,000 PWC homes that are needed. We will worry about the traffic and roads needed for them commuting into Prince William County later.

Our membership chair took this up with her daughter, who teaches in Gainesville. Her daughter asked about the field beside the family home. It’s close to school, and Grandma could walk over after dinner.

We gave her a choice of Stafford or Fauquier. Grandma has a car.

Warmly,
The Western Prince William NIMBY Society

Two crying children stand by the door with their parents. An older couple laughs from the brick porch next door. The man points at the family.

The Western PWC welcome mat.

The children asked if their family could live near their school. We told them every child deserves a home. Then we shut the door before they could ask where.

“Kids can’t have everything they want.”
— Western PWC NIMBY Society

Questions we are asked

Don't you live in a development?
We live in a community. A development is what gets built after you have moved in.
Where will you go when your homes are removed?
Somewhere quiet and unbuilt. Once settled, we will form a group to protect it from people in our exact position.
Is there any new housing you would support?
Yes, in principle. We support housing that is somewhere else, for someone else, at a later date, pending further study.
What was the right year to stop building?
The year ours was finished. The pledge form below will calculate yours.

Get involved.

Suggest a development site.

Where in Eastern Prince William should the next development go? Add a street address or intersection to the Society’s list.

The address and community will appear on the suggestions page.

View all address suggestions

Email the supervisors.

Tell the Board where the Society wants new development to go. The draft copies County Executive Christopher Shorter. Review the draft in your email app and sign it in your own name.

SubjectNIMBY Society - Homes for Kids is not our problem

Development doesn’t belong in Western Prince William County. Please direct all new development to Eastern Prince William County, Stafford County, or Fauquier County.

Open email draft Board contact directory

Pledge your own property.

Ready to start on your side of the fence? Commit to pursuing a conservation easement on your home property.

View the commitment tracker

Support like-minded partners

  • Audacious NIMBY
  • Coalition to Protect Prince William County
  • Prince William Conservation Alliance